AV1, Apple ProRes RAW and JPEG XL are often grouped together in discussions of modern media formats, but they are not direct competitors. AV1 is a video codec; ProRes RAW is a RAW video recording format; JPEG XL is an image coding format. A fair standards review should compare each format with alternatives in the same category and evaluate its role in the production pipeline.
For a practical look at storage throughput and media-processing bottlenecks, see NVMe storage in AI editing workflows.
For the wider history of digital colour and image-format standards, see our guide to the evolution of digital colour management.
AV1: compressed video delivery and storage
AV1 is an open video codec developed by the Alliance for Open Media. It is designed for efficient video compression and supports modern delivery workflows, including high-resolution and HDR applications. The AOMedia specification defines its bitstream and decoding process. See the AV1 specification.
ProRes RAW: camera-originated RAW video
ProRes RAW is designed to preserve RAW image data from supported camera and recorder workflows while applying ProRes-style compression. Its role is acquisition and post-production, not general web delivery. Compatibility depends on the camera output, recorder, software and current support. Do not compare ProRes RAW bitrate or quality directly with AV1 delivery settings without defining the source and purpose.
JPEG XL: still-image coding
JPEG XL is standardised in ISO/IEC 18181 and supports lossy and lossless still-image coding, high bit depths, wide-gamut workflows and other features. It is not a video codec and should be compared with AVIF, WebP and JPEG for still-image applications. See ISO/IEC 18181-1.
Standards and workflow matrix
| Format | Media type | Primary role | Fair comparison set |
|---|---|---|---|
| AV1 | Video | Compressed video distribution and storage | HEVC, AVC, VP9 |
| ProRes RAW | RAW video | Camera acquisition and post-production | Blackmagic RAW, CinemaDNG and other RAW video workflows |
| JPEG XL | Still image | Image storage, exchange and web delivery | AVIF, WebP, JPEG |
What a valid benchmark must measure
For AV1, compare bitrate, quality, encode/decode time, hardware support and licensing under matched video sources. For ProRes RAW, compare camera compatibility, RAW controls, file size, decode performance and post-production support against other RAW formats. For JPEG XL, compare image quality, compression ratio, encode/decode time, metadata and ecosystem support against other still-image formats. Do not combine these measurements into a single cross-category ranking.
For a repeatable methodology to measure GPU inference workloads in production, see our diffusion-model GPU benchmarking framework.
Conclusion
AV1, ProRes RAW and JPEG XL solve different problems in the media chain. Their standards status and workflow fit should be assessed within their own categories. Any performance or licensing comparison requires matched source material, named software versions and a clear statement of the intended use.